There’s a blogger who reads POD books and evaluates them. Recently, she’s been hammering them pretty hard, including posting a number of opening lines that made her put down the book. Now, in order to be fair to POD (I think her point is that crap is everywhere…), whe has a new contest in which entrants are supposed to guess whether the work is vanity or traditional publisher.
Assuming that all the publishers are large and well-respected, it is possible for them to publish crap. It’s also possible for crap to sell very, very, very well. And it’s also possible for an otherwise decent book to have a few crappy lines. And some of these might not be crappy at all in context. Also, the fact that there are SOME crappy commerical books doesn’t mean jack about the average quality of vanity versus commercial fiction. There are depths of incoherence to which commercial fiction NEVER sinks. And there are many, many fewer good vanity books. If this wasn’t true, there would be no editors–major houses would choose books by lottery. They aren’t stupid. The fact remains that there is an enormous divide between the average commercially pubbed book and the average vanity book. Enormous. And a few crappy or out-of-context lines from commercial fiction won’t change that any more than 1 in 100,000 vanity-published books that turn out to be really, really great will change it.
Nevertheless, I will take my guesses.
(BTW, I didn’t think all the previous ones she listed from POD sources were crap. I think some of them were humor that she didn’t get. But that’s just me.)
(1) This is where I came in. Not the beginning, but the middle. I’ve spent my life feeling like I was born at eight years old and I’m about to die at nine, living my life as one long 352-day experience, with all of the abuse and anguish of the year as though it just happened moments ago. But the reflection in the mirror reassures me that I’m actually thirty-nine. I’ll say vanity. Not sure–it has the self-centered, overly self-conscious tone and substancelessness of much lit fic today…but I’ll say vanity.
(2) Francesca takes him, leads him, into the bedroom and opens herself like a rose. Michael stares at her flower and smiles, mounts her like an animal. His smile widens as her rose becomes his. His smile will fade in approximately two weeks when he begins to see the thorns. Flower AND animal? Vanity.
(3) He walks back to our bedroom, muttering and moaning that life blows, in a scary-nervous voice. The idea of broads shoving bucks in my trunks excites me. Now I have a boner, standing at the bathroom mirror in my white underwear. Look at this fucking thing. I wish I knew how to get rid of them. I need to hit the library. Time to get my mind off the boner and back to the hair. Commercial…but BROADS? I mean, who calls women broads? Could be vanity.
(4) He’s got twenty bucks and a true dilemma: buy groceries or buy porn. Porn last longer; he goes with the smut. Kenny has never been considered impractical. Could be either. I’m not sure why she’s going for “crude! everyone will think it’s vanity!”–crude stuff has been selling commercially for years. I’ll say commercial.
(5) So my friend, he buys milk and eggs and sugar and a carrot, all the ingredients for a carrot cake. And Vaseline. Like he’s going home to stick a carrot cake up his butt. Okay. This is actually funny. Could very well be commercial. I don’t know.
(6) Harry locked his mother in the closet. Harry. Please. Not again the TV. Okay, okay, Harry opened the door, then stop playin games with my head. He started walking across the room toward the television set. And don’t bug me. The bad spelling and punctuation wouldn’t make this vanity, but the passage is either missing something or it makes no freaking sense. I’ll guess vanity. But it could still be “street lit.”
(7) “And your point is what? I don’t even care. If you do have a point, keep it to yourself.” She pauses. “No, I do care, tell me.” She pauses again. “No, never mind, just get out.” He starts to leave. “Wait.” He looks back. “Never mind, just go.” He walks out the door and slams it behind him. “Wait!” she yells. Could be either.
(8) “And the fact that you’re not from the campus, that takes it over the top. Because there’s nothing that excites me like the idea of perceptive, intelligent women living in a university town yet having no connection with the school. Just living in the same town, right there, not needing to have anything to do with it. The idea of the intelligent woman in the university town. What is she? Why is she there? It’s a stimulating idea.” Erg. Could be either again.
(9) Acid-induced cloud, I’m all out there, man. I’m feeling the love, the glove, the shove. Let’s shove together. Shove off, man. We’re falling now. You see? Never gonna crash. Slash. Trash. Take the stash. Dig it. Smooth, baby. My guess? Drug scene from a commercial novel. More common in vanity books (whole confessional genre).
(10) Malcolm never made the same mistake twice; he either got it right the first time or he’d spend the entire weekend correcting some half-assed attempt at success, well into mistake eighteen or nineteen. Commercial. May not be my style, but…what’s wrong with it?
(11) His tongue, his tongue, his tongue, so wet and wild, like having a small animal in my mouth, a slithery reptile making its way, now, down my neck, down my body, down, down, down. Oh, ugh. Sounds just like a lit fic love scene. I hope it’s vanity.
(12) No one’s ever held my foot before, Ellie thought, blissfully. Her foot in his hand gave her an inexplicable feeling of safety and belonging that she had never before experienced. I think I love this man, she had thought as the two of them sat silently and her foot melted in his wonderful hand. Foot MELTING. Vanity, I hope.
(13) The bird’s singing became so insistent that I began asking Michael to repeat every word he said. I was a bit annoyed, a bit amused and more than a bit surprised by the bird’s behavior. When I felt I could no longer act nonchalantly about the situation I said to Michael, using an appropriate New Yorkese expression, “What is it with this bird, anyway?” To which Michael matter-of-factly replied, “Oh, that’s George” as if that was all the explanation required for my understanding of the creature’s behavior. “What do you mean, oh that’s George?” I said. “Are you telling me you know this wild bird and that you call him George?” Michael did not offer detailed verbal clarification. Detailed verbal explanation. Vanity.
(14) The rubber met the road. Actually, the rubber was on me, and I was going down a different road: the Hershey Highway. Traffic was light. I hit the gas. I was home in no time. I would hope this would be vanity. (Who the heck under 50 calls them RUBBERS now, anyhow?) But it could be either.
(15) The bell rings, and it’s an incredibly ugly-sounding bell, and I wonder why? Why don’t they have beautiful tones ringing us on to our next class, but I doubt that anyone gives a shit so I’d say that’s why. Copy editing too awful to be commercial. Vanity.
(16) Melanie was hosting another Mary Kay party when I got home, and the ladies were all spread around the family room, evenly spaced like digits on the face of a clock, with that fat-assed Laurie blocking my wide-screen, right at twelve o’clock. Pissed me off something fierce. All I wanted was a little time with my man, Frasier. That Niles Crane? That’s funny shit, man. What is this, Housewives With Potty Mouths? It just doesn’t quite match up. Let’s say vanity.
(17) “She took everything from you. Everything. Everything. All I wanted was a family. That’s all. All I wanted. A family. A family.” Saliva spewed from his mouth and mucus bubbled from his nostrils. Harder and harder he struck, ignoring the pain ripping through his head. “Why? Why? Why!” Vanity.
(18) “Don’t dick with me, cockface–or cock with me, dickface–or whatever the hell it’s supposed to be. You no good dickface.” Probably commercial. Mean to be humorous.
(19) He wished for the thousandth time in his life that he had a dog, a golden retriever, maybe, for travels like this and to keep him company at home. But he was frequently away, overseas much of the time, and it would not be fair to the animal. Still, he thought about it anyway. Babbling stream-of-consciousness. Could be anything.
(20) I feel all the longing of this earth tugging at my sleeves. All the hope that has vanished from every soul seems to pass through me on its way to another place, and I drift with it as it goes. I want to be here. I want to be there, too. All I want is a little omnipresence. Cheesy but saved from awfulness by the humor of the last line. Could be either.
(21) “Don’t cry for me. Don’t remember me. Don’t take anything with you that might bring an image of me to your mind. I want to be forgotten. I want to disintegrate. Move on and leave me behind. Just don’t take the Mercedes when you go. Other than that, forget me.” If humorous, commercial. If in earnest, vanity.
(22) The next night I brought her flowers. I was hoping she would hit me again, call me names, tell me how worthless I am. I rushed home from work every day, hoping. But she wouldn’t do it, not even when I asked. That’s when she really started cheating on me. She said whipping me made her feel bad about herself. Vanity. This is a “descent into S&M confessional novel”–a dime a dozen in the vanity world, not common commercially.
(23) Hers contained a desire beyond sweetness and attention, it fed a longing, beginning to flower green and yellow into a crocuslike lust, the soft petals opening into her awkward adolescence. I hope it’s vanity. I fear it is not.
(24) John, 18, hated his face. If his nose were smaller, his eyes a different brown, his bottom lip pouty . . . As a kid he’d been punched in the mouth and looked great for a couple of weeks. Written by a woman. I’ll guess vanity because of the “18″ inserted like a news story.